I still remember sitting in the theater in 2019, watching Tony Stark snap his fingers and Steve Rogers finally get that dance with Peggy. It felt like a genuine, hard-won conclusion—a rare thing in superhero storytelling. So when I heard that Robert Downey Jr. and Chris Evans were coming back for Avengers: Doomsday, my heart did a weird little somersault. Excitement? Sure. But also a nagging sense of betrayal, like watching a magician saw a woman in half only to reveal she was never in the box at all. That’s the thing about comic book deaths—they’re less a period at the end of a sentence and more a semicolon that the writer can erase whenever sales dip.

death-is-a-revolving-door-my-mixed-feelings-on-avengers-doomsday-image-0

In the comics, nobody stays dead. It’s a tradition as old as the medium itself. Jean Grey has died and returned via the Phoenix Force so many times that her gravestone should have a revolving door installed. Steve Rogers was “assassinated” after Civil War, only to be revealed as displaced in time. Wolverine and Thor had deaths marketed as groundbreaking events, yet they always find a sci-fi loophole. Why? Because iconic characters are multi-billion-dollar assets, and publishers can’t afford to leave them on the shelf. Death is a narrative hurdle, not a final conclusion—a commercial necessity dressed up as cosmic drama.

death-is-a-revolving-door-my-mixed-feelings-on-avengers-doomsday-image-1

And now the MCU is fully embracing that tradition. Avengers: Doomsday and Secret Wars are set to bring back not just Evans’ Steve Rogers (as a variant, apparently) but also Downey Jr. as a mysterious Doctor Doom. It’s a bold move, but it comes at a cost. Avengers: Endgame gave both characters perfect farewells—Tony’s sacrifice and Steve’s peaceful old age. Those endings felt earned. Now, knowing that a new Steve Rogers and a Doom who looks suspiciously like Tony Stark are fighting for the multiverse, I can’t help but feel that the emotional weight of Endgame has been diluted. It’s like a library book that’s always returned with a different cover—sometimes it’s a love story, sometimes a thriller, but the original ending is gone.

death-is-a-revolving-door-my-mixed-feelings-on-avengers-doomsday-image-2

Of course, there are exceptions. Uncle Ben’s death remains the cornerstone of Peter Parker’s morality, and Marvel has respected that for decades. The original Captain Marvel died of cancer, a grounded, human end that stuck. These rare cases prove that when death is permanent, it serves a character’s growth. But those exceptions only highlight the rule: in mainstream superhero comics, death is a temporary inconvenience. The MCU has already resurrected Loki, Gamora, Black Widow, and Quicksilver in various forms. Heimdall appeared in Valhalla. Phil Coulson came back via Project Tahiti. So why should Tony and Steve be any different?

death-is-a-revolving-door-my-mixed-feelings-on-avengers-doomsday-image-3

On a practical level, I get it. Downey Jr. and Evans are still passionate about the MCU, still in great shape, and fans want more of them. There are only so many chances to see them alongside Hugh Jackman, Ryan Reynolds, Tobey Maguire, and Tom Holland. The commercial appeal is undeniable. But I worry that Doomsday will retroactively tarnish Endgame. Knowing that Tony’s snap wasn’t the last we’d see of him, or that Steve’s kiss with Peggy wasn’t his final moment, changes how I’ll rewatch the Infinity Saga. It’s like finding out the final chapter of your favorite book had a hidden epilogue you never asked for.

death-is-a-revolving-door-my-mixed-feelings-on-avengers-doomsday-image-4

That said, Avengers: Secret Wars could offer a soft reboot that restores the original endings. In a new Earth-616, Steve and Tony could remain dead for good, their sacrifices remembered while new variants take up the mantle. That would be the respectful bookend—a way to honor Endgame while still moving forward. But if the MCU keeps resurrecting its fallen heroes without consequence, then death will never feel permanent again. And that’s a shame, because the best stories need real stakes.

As a lifelong Marvel fan, I’ll be first in line for Doomsday. But I’ll also be holding my breath, hoping that this resurrection tango doesn’t turn the MCU into a comic book where the only thing that stays dead is my sense of closure.